Site icon Decode the future

EU AI Act Risk Categories: Is Your AI System High-Risk?

A magnifying lens examines an AI silhouette beside a document and shield, illustrating risk assessment.

Conceptual illustration of assessing the risks of an artificial intelligence system.

Last updated: October 2026 · Legal state checked against the consolidated AI Act after the Digital Omnibus, Regulation (EU) 2026/1744

The EU AI Act sorts AI systems into four risk categories: unacceptable risk (banned), high risk (strict obligations), limited risk (transparency duties) and minimal risk (no specific obligations). A system is high-risk if it is a safety component of a product covered by Annex I, or if it is used in one of the eight Annex III areas, such as hiring, credit scoring, education or biometrics. After the Digital Omnibus, the Annex III obligations apply from 2 December 2027, and the Annex I obligations from 2 August 2028.

Art. 5 · Art. 6 · Art. 50Annex III: 8 areasHigh-risk from 2 Dec 2027

Most pages on this topic list the four tiers and stop there. That does not answer the question compliance teams actually ask: is our system high-risk? Before writing, we compared six top-ranking guides against 22 practical questions. None of them explained who must carry out a fundamental rights impact assessment. Only one said plainly whether a chatbot is high-risk, and only one explained where general-purpose AI models fit. This guide adds a seven-step classification test and a table of common use cases. For the full regulation, including timelines and the GPAI regime, see our EU AI Act explainer.

What are the four EU AI Act risk categories?

CategoryLegal basisWhat it meansApplies fromMaximum fine
Unacceptable riskArt. 5Banned outright2 Feb 2025; added bans from 2 Dec 2026€35m or 7% of turnover
High riskArt. 6, Annex I and IIIRisk management, data governance, logging, human oversight, conformity assessment, registrationAnnex III: 2 Dec 2027 · Annex I: 2 Aug 2028€15m or 3%
Limited riskArt. 50Transparency: tell people they are talking to AI, label deepfakes and synthetic content2 Aug 2026€15m or 3%
Minimal risk—No specific obligations; voluntary codes of conduct——

Two clarifications competitors often skip. First, the categories describe uses, not technologies. The same model can be minimal-risk in a spam filter and high-risk when it ranks job applicants. Second, general-purpose AI models such as large language models sit outside the four tiers. They have their own regime (Articles 51–55, with extra duties above 1025 FLOPs of training compute). A product built on one is classified by what it is used for. Fines are capped at the lower of the two amounts for SMEs and start-ups. Our EU AI Act fines guide covers the details.

Which AI practices are banned under Article 5?

  • subliminal, manipulative or deceptive techniques that materially distort behaviour and cause significant harm;
  • exploiting vulnerabilities linked to age, disability or social or economic situation;
  • social scoring that leads to unjustified or disproportionate detrimental treatment;
  • predicting a person’s risk of committing a crime based solely on profiling or personality traits;
  • untargeted scraping of facial images to build facial recognition databases;
  • emotion recognition in workplaces and schools, except for medical or safety reasons;
  • biometric categorisation to infer race, political opinions, trade union membership, religion, sex life or sexual orientation;
  • real-time remote biometric identification in public spaces for law enforcement, apart from narrow exceptions;
  • from 2 December 2026, added by the Omnibus: AI systems that generate non-consensual intimate imagery or child sexual abuse material.

What makes an AI system high-risk?

Article 6 gives two routes:

  1. Annex I route (products). The AI is a safety component of a product, or is itself a product, covered by EU harmonisation law listed in Annex I (machinery, toys, medical devices, lifts, radio equipment and others), and that product needs a third-party conformity assessment. The Omnibus clarified that features which only assist users or optimise performance, without a safety function, are not safety components.
  2. Annex III route (use cases). The AI is intended for one of eight sensitive areas:
Annex III areaTypical high-risk uses
1. BiometricsRemote biometric identification (not simple identity verification), biometric categorisation by sensitive traits, emotion recognition
2. Critical infrastructureSafety components in digital infrastructure, road traffic, and water, gas, heating or electricity supply
3. EducationAdmissions, grading that steers learning, assessing education level, detecting cheating in tests
4. EmploymentTargeted job ads, CV filtering, candidate evaluation, promotion, termination, task allocation, performance monitoring
5. Essential servicesEligibility for public benefits, credit scoring (fraud detection excluded), life and health insurance pricing, emergency call triage
6. Law enforcementVictim-risk assessment, polygraph-like tools, evidence reliability, re-offending risk, profiling in investigations
7. Migration and bordersPolygraph-like tools, security or health risk assessment, asylum and visa applications, detecting persons
8. Justice and democracyAssisting courts with facts and law, systems intended to influence elections or voting behaviour

When is an Annex III system not high-risk? The Article 6(3) exception

An Annex III system escapes the high-risk category if it poses no significant risk to health, safety or fundamental rights and meets at least one of four conditions. It must:

  • perform a narrow procedural task, for example sorting incoming documents into categories;
  • improve the result of a human activity that is already finished, for example polishing the language of a drafted letter;
  • detect decision-making patterns or deviations without replacing or influencing the human assessment;
  • perform a preparatory task for an assessment, for example translating application files.

Two traps. If the system profiles natural persons, it is always high-risk and the exception does not apply. And using the exception still leaves work to do: the provider must document the assessment and register the system in the EU database (Art. 49(2)). The Commission’s Omnibus proposal would have removed that registration duty. Parliament and Council kept it, and only trimmed the required data fields.

How do you classify your AI system? A 7-step test

EU AI Act risk classification decision flow A seven-step test. Check Article 5 bans first. Then check the Annex I product route and the Annex III use-case route. Profiling always means high risk. Otherwise the Article 6(3) exception can apply, with documentation and registration. Systems that only interact with people or generate content fall under Article 50 transparency. Everything else is minimal risk. EU AI Act risk classification flowDecodeTheFuture.orgeu ai act risk categories, high-risk ai systems, annex iii, article 6(3), article 50Decision flow for classifying an AI system under the EU AI Act after Regulation (EU) 2026/1744.Diagramimage/svg+xmlen© DecodeTheFuture.org 1. Is it an AI system under Art. 3(1)? No → out of scope 2. Is the use banned by Art. 5? Yes → prohibited 3. Safety component of an Annex I product (3rd-party CA)? Yes → high (2028) 4. Intended purpose in one of 8 Annex III areas? No → go to step 6 5. Profiles people? → high. Else: Art. 6(3) condition met? No → high(2 Dec 2027) Yes → not high-risk, but document + register (Art. 49(2)) 6. Talks to people, makes synthetic content, deepfakes or emotion recognition? Yes → limited(Art. 50) 7. None of the above? → minimal risk Re-run the test whenever the intended purpose changes. GPAI models: separate regime (Art. 51–55).

Run the test on the intended purpose stated in your documentation and marketing, not on the model’s technical capabilities. If a deployer repurposes a general tool for an Annex III use, for example using a general chatbot to pre-screen job applicants, the deployer can become the provider of a high-risk system under Article 25.

Is my use case high-risk? Common examples

Use caseCategoryWhy
Customer-service chatbotLimitedMust disclose it is AI (Art. 50(1)). Not high-risk unless it decides an Annex III matter
CV screening or candidate rankingHighAnnex III 4(a); usually involves profiling, so Art. 6(3) cannot apply
Bank credit scoring of consumersHigh + FRIAAnnex III 5(b); deployers must do a fundamental rights impact assessment
Payment fraud detectionNot high-risk under 5(b)Explicitly carved out of the credit-scoring entry
Exam proctoring that flags cheatingHighAnnex III 3(d)
Emotion recognition of employeesProhibitedArt. 5(1)(f); outside work and education it is high-risk under Annex III 1(c)
Diagnostic AI in a medical deviceHigh (Annex I)Medical device law requires notified-body assessment; applies from 2 Aug 2028
AI image generatorLimitedOutputs must be machine-readably marked; deepfakes must be disclosed
Spam filter, recommendation engine for a shopMinimalNo specific obligations

What do providers and deployers of high-risk AI have to do?

Providers, who build the system or sell it under their own name, carry most of the burden. They need a risk management system, data governance, technical documentation, automatic logging, instructions for use, human-oversight design, accuracy and cybersecurity, a quality management system, a conformity assessment, CE marking and registration in the EU database (Arts. 9–17, 43, 49). Deployers, who use the system under their own authority, must follow the instructions, assign competent human oversight, monitor operation, keep logs for at least six months and inform affected workers (Art. 26).

The fundamental rights impact assessment (FRIA) is narrower than many guides suggest. Under Article 27, it applies to deployers that are public bodies or private entities providing public services, and to any deployer of credit scoring (Annex III 5(b)) or life and health insurance pricing (5(c)). It must be done before first use, and the results go to the market surveillance authority. Critical-infrastructure systems (Annex III point 2) are exempt. Public-authority deployers also register their use in the EU database (Art. 49(3)).

What is still unsettled in 2026?

Article 6(5) required the Commission to publish practical guidelines on high-risk classification by 2 February 2026. It missed that date. Draft guidelines appeared on 19 May 2026, a targeted consultation closed on 23 June 2026, and the final version is expected by the end of 2026. Until then, borderline cases, especially the Article 6(3) conditions, depend on your own documented reasoning. Harmonised standards for high-risk requirements are also still being finalised. That is one reason the Omnibus moved the Annex III deadline to December 2027.

What does this mean in practice?

Start with an inventory, not a policy. List every AI system you build or use, write down its intended purpose in one sentence and run the seven-step test. Most organisations find that most of their systems are minimal or limited risk. The work concentrates on a few systems in hiring, credit, insurance, education or biometrics, and that is where the 14 months before December 2027 should go. To link the classification to an existing risk programme, see NIST AI RMF vs ISO 42001 vs the AI Act. If credit is your domain, our explainer on AI credit scoring shows what the models actually do. A Polish version of this guide is available: systemy wysokiego ryzyka w AI Act.

FAQ

What are the 4 risk levels of the EU AI Act?

Unacceptable risk (banned practices under Article 5), high risk (Annex I products and Annex III use cases with strict obligations), limited risk (transparency duties under Article 50) and minimal risk (no specific obligations).

Is ChatGPT or a chatbot high-risk under the EU AI Act?

Not by default. A chatbot is limited risk and must tell users they are interacting with AI. It becomes high-risk only if it is used for an Annex III purpose, such as screening job applicants or deciding eligibility for public benefits. The underlying model is regulated separately as a general-purpose AI model.

When do the high-risk obligations apply?

After the Digital Omnibus (Regulation (EU) 2026/1744), obligations for Annex III high-risk systems apply from 2 December 2027, and those for AI in Annex I regulated products from 2 August 2028.

Can an Annex III system avoid being high-risk?

Yes, under Article 6(3), if it poses no significant risk and only performs a narrow procedural, improving, pattern-detecting or preparatory task. It never applies to systems that profile natural persons, and the provider must still document the assessment and register the system.

Who needs a fundamental rights impact assessment?

Deployers of high-risk systems that are public bodies or private entities providing public services, plus any deployer of AI credit scoring or life and health insurance pricing. Critical-infrastructure systems are exempt.

What is the fine for using a prohibited AI system?

Up to €35 million or 7% of worldwide annual turnover, whichever is higher. For SMEs and start-ups, the lower of the two amounts applies.

Exit mobile version